Ever Wonder What the Difference Between a Sociopath and Psychopath?

Antisocial (song)

Antisocial (song) (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

So did I.

I think most people are confused when they hear these terms. When I started into the mental health profession I learned these are the SAME condition. Only here in the USA we describe both as the anti-social personality.

A sociologists sees the causes of this type of personality, are due to social factors and prefer the term sociopath. The term psychopathy may be preferred by psychologists who see the causes as due to a combination of psychological, genetic, and environmental factors. Both require the person as having a personality disorder. Most commonly Anti-Social Personality Disorder, described in the DSM-IV-TR, here in the United States.

HISTORY

In 1891 Julius Ludwig August Koch formally introduced the concept of “psychopathic inferiority” (psychopathischen minderwertigkeiten). This also referred to diverse kinds of dysfunction or strange conduct in the absence of obvious mental illness or retardation. Habitual criminality was only a small part of his concept, but the public soon used the shortened version “inferiors” to refer to anyone supposedly suffering from an inherent disposition toward crime.

02 Dr. Hervey Milton Cleckley

Dr. Hervey Milton Cleckley (Photo credit: Image Editor)

The Mask of Sanity by Hervey M. CleckleyM.D., first published in 1941, is considered a seminal work which provided a vivid series of case studies of individuals described as psychopaths. Cleckley proposed 16 characteristics of psychopathy, derived mainly from his work with male psychiatric patients in a locked institution.

The title refers to the “mask” of normal functioning that Cleckley thought concealed the disorganization, amorality and disorder of the psychopathic personality. This marked the start in America of the current clinical and popularise conception of psychopathy as a particular type of antisocial, emotionless and criminal character. Cleckley would produce five editions of the book over subsequent decades, including a substantial revision in 1950, expanding his case studies and theories to more non-prisoners and non-criminals.

Cleckley’s concept of psychopathy, particularly in the sense of a conscience-less man beneath a mask of normality, caught the public imagination. However, the book fell out of favor, and when he died in 1984 Cleckley was better remembered for a vivid case study of a female patient published in 1956, turned into a movie The Three Faces of Eve in 1957, which had (re) popularized in America another controversial diagnosis, Multiple Personality Disorder.

The first version of the American Psychiatric Association‘s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders in 1952 did not use the term psychopath, but instead “sociopathic personality disturbance”, although it included many of Cleckley’s criteria. The diagnosis had antisocial or dissocial subtypes, though the latter was deleted in the DSM-II. The diagnosis was only one within a broader category that would be termed personality disorders.

A distinction was proposed by psychoanalyst Benjamin Karpman from the 1940s between psychopathy due to psychological problems (e.g. psychotic, hysterical or neurotic conditions) and idiopathic psychopathy where there was no obvious psychological cause. He concluded that the former could not be attributed to a psychopathic personality.

Meanwhile, criminologist sociologists William and Joan McCord were influential in narrowing the definition of psychopathy to an antisocial lack of the guilt emotion and reactive aggression. On the other hand, various analysts purported to identify “successful” psychopaths in society, some even suggesting it was but an adoption to the social or economic mores of the age, others noting they could be hard to spot either because they were so good at hiding their lack of conscience, or because many people showed the traits to some degree.

However, there remained NO international clinical agreement on the diagnosis of psychopathy. A 1977 study found little relationship with the characteristics commonly attributed to psychopaths and concluded that the concept was being used too widely and loosely.

Robert D. Hare  published a book in 1970 summarizing research on psychopathy, and was subsequently at the forefront of psychopathy research. Frustrated by a lack of agreed definitions or rating systems for psychopathy, including at a ten-day international North Atlantic Treaty Organization conference in 1975, Hare began developing his Psychopathy Checklist.

06 Hare’s Psychopathy Checklist-Revised (PCL-R)

Hare’s Psychopathy Checklist-Revised (PCL-R) (Photo credit: Image Editor)

Produced in 1980, it was based partly on the list of traits advanced by Cleckley and partly on the theories of other authors and on his own experiences with clients in prisons. Meanwhile, also in the wake of the NATO conference, a DSM-III task force instead developed the diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder, published in the DSM in 1980.This was based on some of the criteria put forward by Cleckley but operationalized in behavioral rather than personality terms, more specifically related to conduct. APA was most concerned to demonstrate inter-rater reliability rather than necessarily validity.

Hare revised his checklist PCL-R  (Psychopathy Checklist-Revised ) as a draft in 1985 (removing two items) and then finalized it as the first edition in 1991. Meanwhile, following some criticism over the lack of psychological criteria in the DSM, further studies were conducted leading up the DSM-IV in 1994 and some personality criteria were included as “associated features” which were outlined in the text. The ICD (The International Statistical Classification of Diseases) produced by World Health Organization’s,  incorporated a similar diagnosis of Dissocial Personality Disorder. Both state that psychopathy (or sociopathy) may be considered synonyms of their diagnosis.

Hare updated the PCL-R with extra data in a 2nd edition in 2003. He has also written two bestsellers on psychopathy, “Without Conscience” in 1993 and “Snakes in Suits” in 2006.

Despite being unused as the main term in diagnostic manuals, the term ‘psychopath’ is still used by some mental health professionals and by the general public, popular press and in fictional portrayals.

Next time we will the difference in the United States DSM-IV-TR and ICD more commonly used in Europe.

 

Resources used: Wikipedia, DSM-IV-TR, Clinical Assessment and Diagnosis in Social Work Practice, by Jacqueline Corcoran and Joseph Walsh pages 470-473, and http://www.cassiopaea.com/cassiopaea/cleckley-mos.htm.

Here are a couple of reading suggestions:

The Sociopath Next Door, by: Martha Stout, Without Conscience: The Disturbing World of the Psychopaths Among Us, by: Robert D. Hare, and

Mask of Sanity by Hervey Cleckley PDF – book download FREE! http://www.cassiopaea.org/cass/sanity_1.PdF

**Please feel free to add more to my list!**

15 thoughts on “Ever Wonder What the Difference Between a Sociopath and Psychopath?

  1. lifebegins45 says:

    Hi Diane. Thank you for the ‘ping back’. Your blog is very informative and well written. I appreciate different views on the subject of ‘sociopath’ vs. ‘psychopath’. In my case I tend to see them as 2 different types belonging to the realm of ‘ASPD’. The identifiers of the Sociopath didn’t fit my X but he does fit ALL of the criteria associated with a Psychopath.

    He’s held the same job with the same company for 10 years. He doesn’t make quick decisions..everything is well thought out and planned. He didn’t break up with me…in fact he fought HARD to keep me in his life, though it wasn’t out of love. I was someone he conquered and didn’t want to lose the source of supply. I had to literally run from him, fighting, kicking and screaming along the way. I TRIED to get him so flustered and angry, that he WOULD break up with me! Nope…

    These are some of the things that make me believe the 2 are different. I also understand the debate is commonplace among professionals. I’m not a professional. I’m viewing this from my own perspective and experience.

    I wish you luck with your new book…sounds like a very exciting and informative read!
    I’m happy to meet you 🙂

    • dianekratz says:

      Very happy to meet you as well. And you are right about this being a professional debate. Neither sociopath or psychopath are listed in the current DSM. But a new version is coming next year and hopefully it will define this type of personality better. There are plenty of functioning Sociopath/Psychopath'(s) running around world, playing havoc with peoples lives. People who look normal to everyone else as suck the very souls out of others around them. I wish you the best and I’m happy you’ve gotten him out of your life. A good book to read is called, “The Sociopath Next Door” by: Martha Stout. God Bless and thank you for stopping by.
      Diane Kratz

  2. how to study says:

    Cheers, I just stopped in to visit your site and thought I’d say I enjoyed myself.

  3. larissahoffman says:

    Excellent post as always. I thought about this the other day while watching the movie YA. The main character (the YA author) was supposed to have depression, but she seemed to have an anti-social personality disorder to me. She exhibited no empathy and was completely narcissistic. I think I would have enjoyed the movie more if they made that clear or changed her personality.
    I also thought about it with The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo. These characters certainly make interesting fiction but I wouldn’t want to deal with them in real life!
    I wonder if these kinds of characters have exaggerated symptoms of anti-social disorders?
    Very interesting.

  4. marsharwest says:

    Super info, Diane. Reading about folks like this can be scary entertaining, but dealing with them in real life can be deadly. The villian in my current WIP has that entitled & lack of empathy thing going for him, but very charasmatic–draws people to him. I hadn’t consciously realized that’s how I was writing him–even after filling out all my character charts. LOL I can bump him up a notch or two now. Thanks for this informative blog.

  5. dianekratz says:

    Larissa I’m so happy you stopped by. Writing about a true sociopath is really hard, because they simply have no emotions or connections to another person. They in a sense, lack a personality.

    Writers must incorporate one into them, and usually we take them to the extreme. I think this is one of the reasons they are so popular in movies. Most sociopath’s do not go around murdering people psychically. They do it psychologically, financially and legally.

    In America we don’t like to brand people with a negative label. I believe this is why the USA have resisted the above mentioned labels.

    My own personal opinion, I do think there is a difference between a sociopath (which is closer to the USA version of the ASPD) and a psychopath.

    Psychopath’s are more criminal. These are the serial killers,rapist, grifters, bombers, and family annihilator’s. I’m hoping in 2013 when the new, updated version of DSM comes out, to will include a more detailed descriptions and will included both.

    Diane Kratz

  6. […] Ever Wonder What the Difference Between a Sociopath and Psychopath? (profilesofmurder.wordpress.com) Share this:ShareEmailPrintDigg Pin ItShare on TumblrLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. […]

  7. […] Ever Wonder What the Difference Between a Sociopath and Psychopath? (profilesofmurder.wordpress.com) […]

  8. […] Ever Wonder What the Difference Between a Sociopath and Psychopath? « Profiles of Murder […]

  9. hiii111 says:

    I belive a Sociopath may be able to bond with some, but with difficulty and they may have little more morality than psychopaths, maybe, i don’t know.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s